Dad raced home when daughter, 13, died but was put in Covid lockdown. Taxpayers are paying the price
The tragic reason why an international lawyer sued the Victorian Government after being trapped in hotel quarantine can finally be revealed.
Hayden Flinn’s two-week court battle over the state’s decision to refuse him and his son a quarantine exemption was set to begin on Tuesday before it was quietly settled on the morning of the trial.

No details have been released on the settlement, but the Daily Mail can reveal Mr Flinn and his son had flown from Hong Kong to Melbourne in May 2021.
Sophie, Mr Flinn’s troubled 13-year-old daughter, had just taken her own life on May 2.
But despite Mr Flinn and his son both being fully vaccinated, Victorian health officials insisted they be held in a Melbourne hotel under Victoria’s strict quarantine laws.
They were still trapped there for a further two weeks while the rest of the family grieved without them and planned the teenager’s funeral.
Sophie had been a talented basketballer, who had studied at the Australian International School in Hong Kong, where her dad remains a governor.
Mr Flinn had been in Hong Kong where he works as a corporate lawyer, when word of his daughter’s death reached him.
The devastated father completed two Covid tests, which both turned up negative, and flew aboard a Cathay Pacific flight into Melbourne as a fully vaccinated traveller with two doses of Pfizer.
What followed next was a traumatic two weeks locked in a small Richmond hotel room with his distraught teenage son after the pair were refused permission to quarantine with family at home.
On May 3, 2021, the day after Sophie died, there was just one new case of Covid-19 recorded in Victoria and no new locally acquired cases.
The state had not been in lockdown since February.
At the time, Victorians had already been punished through three lockdowns that began in March the previous year.
After 159 days in isolation, Victorians were just weeks away from their fourth Covid-19 lockdown, which began on May 27 and ran until June 10 that year.
In his now settled lawsuit, Mr Flinn claimed he was barred from viewing his daughter’s body and could not be with his distressed wife as she planned their child’s funeral.
He sued the state of Victoria and the Department of Health for damages, claiming he suffered ‘indignity and insult’, a loss of liberty and mental distress.
The trial was set to hear from a string of witnesses including former chief health officer Brett Sutton and his deputy, Allen Cheng, about the decision-making process around Mr Flinn’s case and other exemptions given during the pandemic.
Court documents in Mr Flinn’s case alleged the government was aware of why he needed to leave, but continued to hold him in quarantine, The Age reported.
‘The level of distress being experienced by the family was assessed as too high for the family to maintain [detention] requirements,’ a Health Department email, sent on May 4, 2021, read.
‘The alternative of going home to wife and family would pose a COVID-19 risk to family and public health.’
Mr Flinn had alleged ‘the decisions recorded in Detention Notices 1 and 2 were unlawful and/or incorrect’, court documents stated.
Court records contained an email sent from Mr Flinn to the Health Department asking it to let him and his son out.
‘Her body is at the Coroner’s Court. I would like to leave the hotel to see her. Thank you. Hayden,’ he wrote.
When his request was denied, he emailed the Health Department again, raising fears of his teenage son being locked in a room with him while he was in a state of severe grief.
As emails continued to bounce between different departments, including Sutton’s, it was confirmed the family’s exemption request to move to home quarantine had been denied.
In the three weeks before Mr Flinn’s request, government records showed Covid-19 Quarantine Victoria was made aware of 236 exemption requests, four of which were approved on the grounds of exceptional medical needs.
Mr Flinn and his son were finally allowed to leave the hotel about 5.30pm on May 17, 2021, after completing their fortnight of seclusion.
His daughter was laid to rest on May 22, 2021, almost three weeks after her death.
The Daily Mail does not suggest Sophie’s death was linked to any lockdown or Covid restriction.
While the settlement figure will likely remain confidential, legal sources suggest it was substantial, given the corporate lawyer’s enthusiasm to take the case to trial.
Mr Flinn was set to address reporters about his case on Thursday but pulled out after the case was formally settled.
The Daily Mail contacted him for comment but did not receive a response.
Earlier this week, in an entirely different case in the Coroners Court of Victoria, Coroner Catherine Fitzgerald heard about the death of Natalie Boyce, 21, five weeks after a Moderna booster, and about how Covid hospital visiting restrictions affected her mother, single mum Deborah Hamilton.
Ms Hamilton has long accused former Premier Daniel Andrews of getting special treatment while he was in hospital with an injured back in 2021.
She claimed an Alfred nurse told her that Mr Andrews was allowed visitors whenever he wanted, with no time limits, while he was in hospital.
Ms Hamilton told a Senate committee in May 2023: ‘Daniel Andrews forced us.’
‘I think Dan Andrews is the most corrupt person out there, and I don’t understand why he has different rules than the rest of us.
‘It is just so unfair.’
In March 2026, the Victorian Government, under former Premier Jacinta Allan, settled a class action brought by retail businesses for $125million over the hotel quarantine debacle.
The settlement was approved by the Supreme Court of Victoria on October 21.
That claim alleged that operational failures in the hotel quarantine program, particularly outbreaks linked to the Rydges and Stamford Plaza hotels, caused Victoria’s second Covid-19 wave and the subsequent Stage 3 and Stage 4 lockdowns from July to October 2020.
The Victorian Government settled without admitting any wrongdoing.
